Data Analysis: US conventional power investment increases as renewables investment recedes


Conventional power investment in the US increased from 2012 to 2014, while renewables project investment has mostly fallen over that period.

In 2012, almost $14 billion of investment closed for renewables, according to IJGlobal data. That year, about $6 billion closed for conventional power. But in 2014, that dynamic reversed; conventional power closed more than $16 billion of investment, while renewables closed $9 billion.

Conventional power owes its increased deal volumes to a rise of greenfield gas-fired projects, and specifically those located in the PJM Interconnection market (spanning the mid-Atlantic) and in New England. Both markets anticipate increased energy demand due to the retirements of older coal- and oil-fired plants. Furthermore, gas-fired projects in PJM are also situated near cheap natural gas found in area shale basins, including the Marcellus.

A spate of gas-fired projects closed in 2014 and more should close by year-end 2015 in New England and the PJM market. Panda Power Funds’ 778MW Stonewall in Virginia, Competitive Power Ventures' 725MW St Charles in Maryland and Energy Investors Funds' 869MW Oregon Clean Energy in Ohio are among the projects that closed financings in 2014.

The first half of 2015 showed a modest volume for conventional power, but many large gas-fired projects are in early stages of financing and should close by year-end. Most are located in PJM, which includes Maryland, Ohio, Pennsylvania and West Virginia:

Sponsor/Developer

Project name

State

Size (MW)

Status

NTE Energy

Middletown

Ohio

525

Debt launched

NTE Energy

Kings Mountain

North Carolina

475

Lead banks mandated

NTE Energy

Pecan Creek

Texas

237

Early

Panda

Hummel Station

Pennsylvania

1,000

In talks with lenders

Panda

Mattawoman

Maryland

859

Early

Invenergy

Lackawanna

Pennsylvania

1,300

In talks with lenders

Clean Energy Future

Lordstown

Ohio

940

Equity raise

Energy Solutions Consortium

Moundsville

West Virginia

565

Advisor mandated

Advanced Power, GE, Marubeni

Cricket Valley

New York

1,000

Early

Moxie Energy, Caithness

Moxie Freedom

Pennsylvania

900

In talks with lenders

CPV, GE

Towantic

Connecticut

785

In talks with lenders

Meanwhile, fewer utility-scale greenfield renewable projects are seeking finance today than in 2012, which has contributed to the fall in investment. Renewables often need long-term power purchase agreements (PPA) to be financeable, but such contracts have become scarcer as states reach their mandated renewable portfolio standards.

So, the renewables markets have had to become more differentiated to find opportunities.

Since 2013 wind financings underpinned by hedges – in lieu of PPAs – have become more common, especially in Texas. Alterra and Starwood’s Shannon wind and Pattern’s Panhandle 1 wind farms have closed with hedges.

Portfolios of distributed generation (DG) solar projects are also seeking finance today. Smaller projects are finding PPAs with homeowners and corporates. SolarCity has closed three securitisations backing DG portfolios, and began marketing a fourth this week. Sunrun, True Green Capital and AES have all closed commercial bank debt backing residential solar portfolios.

Snapshots

Asset Snapshot

CPV St Charles Energy Center (745MW)


Value:
USD 896.64m
Full Details
Asset Snapshot

Cricket Valley Combined-Cycle Gas-Fired Plant (1020MW)


Value:
USD 1,584.00m
Full Details
Asset Snapshot

Panhandle Wind Farm (218MW)


Value:
USD 500.00m
Full Details
Asset Snapshot

Hummel CCGT Power Plant (1124MW)


Est. Value:
USD 1,260.00m
Full Details
Asset Snapshot

Mattawoman CCGT Power Plant (990MW)


Est. Value:
USD 1,300.00m
Full Details
Asset Snapshot

Potomac Energy Center (778MW)


Value:
USD 800.00m
Full Details
Asset Snapshot

Middletown Gas-Fired Energy Center (475MW)


Value:
USD 644.70m
Full Details
Asset Snapshot

Kings Mountain Energy Center (475MW)


Value:
USD 605.00m
Full Details
Asset Snapshot

237MW Pecan Creek Energy Center


Est. Value:
USD 200.00m
Full Details
Asset Snapshot

Oregon Clean Energy CCGT Plant (869MW)


Est. Value:
USD 850.00m
Full Details
Asset Snapshot

South Plains Wind Farm (200MW)


Value:
USD 254.00m
Full Details
Asset Snapshot

Moxie Freedom Gas-Fired Plant (1050MW)


Value:
USD 891.68m
Full Details
Asset Snapshot

Lordstown CCGT Plant (940MW)


Est. Value:
USD 891.00m
Full Details
Asset Snapshot

Towantic Energy Combined-Cycle Gas-Fired Plant (785MW)


Value:
USD 1,003.00m
Full Details
Asset Snapshot

Moundsville Gas-Fired Plant (549MW)


Est. Value:
USD 600.00m
Full Details
Asset Snapshot

Shannon Wind Farm (204MW)


Value:
USD 631.00m
Full Details
Transaction Snapshot

Cricket Valley Energy Center (1100MW)


Financial Close:
24/01/2017
SPV:
Cricket Valley Energy Center, LLC
Value:
$1,584.00m USD
Equity:
$532.00m
Debt:
$1,052.00m
Debt/Equity Ratio:
66:34
Full Details
Transaction Snapshot

Panhandle Wind Farm Bridge Financing (218MW)


Financial Close:
19/08/2013
SPV:
Pattern Panhandle Wind LLC, Panhandle B Holdco LLC
Value:
$427.50m USD
Equity:
$90.00m
Debt:
$337.50m
Debt/Equity Ratio:
79:21
Full Details
Transaction Snapshot

Hummel CCGT Power Plant (1124MW)


Financial Close:
27/10/2015
SPV:
Hummel Station, LLC
Value:
$1,283.70m USD
Equity:
$384.00m
Debt:
$899.70m
Debt/Equity Ratio:
70:30
Full Details
Transaction Snapshot

Mattawoman CCGT Power Plant (990MW) Additional Facility


SPV:
Mattawoman Finance LLC
Value:
$14.63m USD
Equity:
$0.00m
Debt:
$14.63m
Debt/Equity Ratio:
100:0
Full Details
Transaction Snapshot

CPV St Charles Energy Center (725MW)


Financial Close:
08/08/2014
SPV:
CPV Maryland
Value:
$896.64m USD
Equity:
$347.00m
Debt:
$549.64m
Debt/Equity Ratio:
61:39
Full Details
Transaction Snapshot

Solarcity Hammerhead Solar PV Portfolio


Financial Close:
04/02/2014
SPV:
Hammerhead Solar
Value:
$220.00m USD
Equity:
$0.00m
Debt:
$220.00m
Debt/Equity Ratio:
100:0
Full Details
Transaction Snapshot

Middletown Gas-Fired Energy Center (478MW)


Financial Close:
02/10/2015
SPV:
NTE Ohio, LLC
Value:
$611.70m USD
Equity:
$210.00m
Debt:
$401.70m
Debt/Equity Ratio:
66:34
Full Details
Transaction Snapshot

Kings Mountain Energy Center (475MW)


Financial Close:
11/03/2016
SPV:
NTE Carolinas, LLC
Value:
$605.26m USD
Equity:
$218.00m
Debt:
$387.26m
Debt/Equity Ratio:
64:36
Full Details
Transaction Snapshot

Pecan Creek Energy Center (237MW)


Value:
$200.00m USD
Full Details
Transaction Snapshot

Stonewall CCGT Power Plant (778MW)


Financial Close:
17/11/2014
Value:
$800.00m USD
Equity:
$229.00m
Debt:
$571.00m
Debt/Equity Ratio:
71:29
Full Details
Transaction Snapshot

Oregon Clean Energy CCGT Power Plant (869MW)


Financial Close:
14/11/2014
SPV:
Oregon Clean Energy
Value:
$994.19m USD
Equity:
$412.09m
Debt:
$582.10m
Debt/Equity Ratio:
59:41
Full Details
Transaction Snapshot

Sunrun Solar Portfolio


Financial Close:
08/01/2015
Value:
$195.00m USD
Debt:
$195.00m
Debt/Equity Ratio:
100:0
Full Details
Transaction Snapshot

South Plains Wind Project (200MW)


Financial Close:
10/11/2014
Value:
$254.00m USD
Full Details
Transaction Snapshot

Lordstown CCGT Plant (940MW)


Financial Close:
06/04/2016
SPV:
Clean Energy Future - Lordstown, LLC
Value:
$891.96m USD
Equity:
$372.96m
Debt:
$519.00m
Debt/Equity Ratio:
58:42
Full Details
Transaction Snapshot

CPV Towantic Energy Combined-Cycle Gas-Fired Plant (785MW)


Financial Close:
11/03/2016
SPV:
CPV Towantic, LLC
Value:
$1,144.93m USD
Equity:
$391.13m
Debt:
$753.80m
Debt/Equity Ratio:
66:34
Full Details
Transaction Snapshot

Moundsville Gas-Fired Plant (549MW)


SPV:
Moundsville Power, LLC
Value:
$600.00m USD
Full Details
Transaction Snapshot

True Green Capital Portfolio Refinancing 2015


SPV:
True Green Capital Project Subsidiaries
Value:
$1,000.00m USD
Equity:
$0.00m
Debt:
$1,000.00m
Debt/Equity Ratio:
100:0
Full Details
Transaction Snapshot

MySolar Portfolio Financing


Financial Close:
26/06/2015
Value:
$75.00m USD
Equity:
$0.00m
Debt:
$75.00m
Debt/Equity Ratio:
100:0
Full Details
Transaction Snapshot

Sunrun Residential Solar Portfolio Securitisation


Value:
$111.00m USD
Equity:
$0.00m
Debt:
$111.00m
Debt/Equity Ratio:
100:0
Full Details
Transaction Snapshot

Shannon Wind Farm (204MW)


Financial Close:
30/06/2015
SPV:
Shannon Wind LLC
Value:
$630.71m USD
Equity:
$343.81m
Debt:
$286.90m
Debt/Equity Ratio:
45:55
Full Details